Duck Dynasty: Canary in the Coal Mine
Once upon a time, in this fair land, a quote incorrectly attributed to Voltaire was held in very high esteem:
"I do not agree with what you have to say, but I'll defend to the death your right to say it."
Once upon a time, disagreement was not a sin, and the stifling of free speech was considered far more offensive than almost anything else.
Almost anything, save for foul language, scatology, graphic violence, and pornography, which were censored.
My, my, Mildred, how things have changed.
Disagreement with certain politically correct beliefs is now considered the greatest offense of all by those who reign over our increasingly hypersensitive liberal-secular culture, and the phony quote from Voltaire is only applied to foul language, scatology, graphic violence, and pornography.
This is why Martin "Banshee" Bashir at MSNBC was not fired right away for his pornographic/scatological remarks concerning Sarah Palin, but the Duck Dynasty guy was fired immediately for expressing his Christian values a bit too firmly.
Those of us who have lived under totalitarian regimes tend to see this change as a very dangerous trade-off.
So, even if you have never watched "Duck Dynasty" you might want to start caring about the way this show is being censored.
Like the canaries they used to bring down into the coal mines, who alerted the miners to unsafe air when they keeled over and died, the Ducksters are a warning to us all.
This might turn out to be a significant skirmish in the culture wars, and a pyrrhic victory for so-called progressives.
The silver lining in this noxious cloud: Free enterprise is not yet dead, so some other network might be more than happy to pick up the show.
Duck Dynasty: The Show That Got Away
By Pat Archbold, National Catholic Register
After A&E fired Phil Robertson for saying what every good Christian should believe, social media has been abuzz. One of the recurring themes has been puzzlement about why A&E would cut off its nose to spite its face. Duck Dynasty is the franchise right now. Why would they risk destroying their own cash cow?
To understand the why, we have to go back to the beginning. Duck Dynasty is not the show that they wanted, it is the show that got away from them.
It seems what the producers intended and what A&E envisioned with the show is much different than the show that they ended up with, but they didn't do anything about it because it was so wildly popular and so wildly profitable. But even with all the money, they have never really been comfortable with what happened.
This is what happened. The whole idea of the show was to parade these nouveau riche Christian hillbillies around so that we could laugh at them. "Look at them," we were supposed to say. "Look how backward they are! Look what they believe! Can you believe they really live this way and believe this stuff? See how they don't fit in? HAHAHA"
When the producers saw the way the show was shaping up, different than they envisioned it, they tried to change course. They tried to get the Robertson's to tone down their Christianity, but to their eternal credit they refused. They tried to add fake cussin' to the show by inserting bleeps where no cussword was uttered. At best, they wanted to make the Robertson's look like crass buffoons. At worst they wanted them to look like hypocrites.
They desperately wanted us to laugh at the Robertsons. Instead, we loved them.
A&E wanted us to point fingers at them and laugh at them. But something else happened entirely. Millions upon millions of people tuned in, not to laugh at them, but to laugh with them.
And then we pointed at them. We pointed at them and said things like, "I wish my family was more like them. I wish we prayed together as a family. I wish we were together like the Robertsons."
By the time this all happened, A&E had a conundrum. They knew who the Robertsons were and what they believe and they still held it in disdain. But they really liked the money. Really liked the money. So they lived with it.
But the progressives whose bank accounts were not growing fatter because of these backward rubes were never inclined to look the other way. They hate the show and they really hate the response to the show. They want it destroyed.
Many magazines and interviewers have tried to get the Robertsons to trip up so they could pounce. When Phil backed the Christian viewpoint on homosexuality and added some personal asides about how he just couldn't understand it, they had their moment.
I suspect that the folks at A&E, who always disliked the positive Christian message in the show of which Phil is the primary proponent, saw their chance. They want to keep the cash but dial down the Christianity. With Phil out, perhaps they could get the show they always wanted.
I suspect that the Robertsons are more principled than that and A&E will end up disappointed on many levels. The Roberstons are who they are and I suspect the money means a great deal more to A&E than it does to them.
It will be interesting to see whether A&E likes the money more than they hate the Christianity. I wouldn't be surprised if the hate wins.